Brand Reputation in the Age of Viral Outrage: A New Rule Book
What to Do When Your Brand Is Being Roasted Online
With the speed of social media and a decrease in media literacy, cancel culture is at an all-time high. Consumers can turn one bad experience with a brand, an awkward statement from corporate, or a
tone-deaf campaign into a viral outcry for reputation murder. When brands hit that point, the Internet stands as a rigid judge; getting back into the good graces of the public eye, from there, becomes
an art form. What would have worked in the past – a polished, professional reply with white text over a black screen – now reads like high-corporate cringe. In its place, netizens respond well to only
two things in earnest: humor and humility.
No brand is perfect, nor are the people running one. Mistakes are bound to happen. In a world where everything is on the Internet and nothing is free from scrutiny, that manifests as one misstep
suddenly becoming a stranger’s viral Story Time video that puts your business on the chopping block. Your brand reputation, and its fate, lies squarely on the timeliness and tone of the response.
Namely, how that tone lines up with the severity and verity of the criticism.
When Humor Is the Right Move
Let’s say, for example, that you are a small makeup company accused of drop-shipping your products by a nano-influencer on Instagram. This influencer hinges her argument on the bare-bones packaging
her order arrived in, and the label on her products peeling off of the minimalist bottles. She claims, therefore, that you ordered your products from a low-quality factory and slapped your brand name
onto the bottles you received for the sake of turning profit. You know, however, that you make all of your products in-house, and that each product is hand-labeled by yourself and your tiny team.
Suddenly, you have quite a bit of content inspiration. Instead of replying to the claims directly, you post Reels of you and your team putting in the work, stitched with the offending commentary, all
while looking at the camera confused. Now, this slanderous narrative has turned comical, solidifying your brand reputation as not only legitimate, but savage and relatable at the same time. You now have
visual proof of your efforts that you can point any future naysayers towards, while the Internet at large is endeared by your brand’s sense of humor.
When to Take It Seriously
In the occasion where the cancellation of your brand may be warranted, however, you may need to tread less jovially. Consider: a relatively popular clothing brand that usually champions diversity and
progressive ideologies does an advertisement spot with an actor who is embroiled in a sexual assault case. Now the Internet is up in arms over a brand platforming an abuser and “flipping” on their
supposed values. This is not a topic to which a brand should respond with levity. A to-camera apology video could become a meme that backfires regarding their brand reputation. What Mad Hat Maven would
recommend, instead, is to put their money and advocacy where their mouth is. After pulling the offending advertisements, posts regarding charity donations, specifically towards those championing sexual
abuse survivors, would do wonders. Furthermore, there should be at least one carousel that outlines the criticism they have received on the matter with actionable ways they intend to respond directly to
those criticisms. This shows accountability that consumers can follow and for which they can hold the brand accountable.
How to Prepare Before a Crisis Hits
While we cannot anticipate every potential fallout a brand reputation may endure, here are a few ways to prepare for social media crises that will not end in a reputation implosion:
- Background check every collaborator you bring on, be they for business ventures or advertisement material. Do not go off of metrics alone: a large follower count or steady stream of business does
not an unproblematic person make. - Always workshop promotional concepts with the audience you are trying to reach beforehand, if possible. A forty-year-old White man is not going to know what is offensive or not to Black teenage
girls. If you do not have the demographic for your brand on your team, fix that. - Do not participate in visual trends, memes, or viral discourse if you are only going to provide a halfhearted, boilerplate addition. Netizens can tell from a mile away when there is legitimate joy
in something versus a grab for relevancy. The joke phrase “silence, brand!” exists in the lifeblood of social media culture for a reason.
Why Cancel Culture Hits So Hard
What you need to keep in mind about cancel culture is this: people use the Internet as a source of power. Be that for good – bringing to light social injustices that have gone unchecked for too long,
for example – or for evil – a defamation of an entire brand based off of the dislike of a singular person – it is no less true. Furthermore, the barrier between brand and consumer is gossamer thin
these days. The advent of social media means that brand reputation is synonymous, in a customer’s mind, with a person’s reputation. Brands are entities to which others can adhere their personalities,
things on which some may begin to hinge their identity. So when a brand fails to meet an unspoken moral expectation, it feels more like a personal slight than a corporate mishap. A mishap that
consumers, now more than ever, feel they have the means to rectify or, at the very least, bring to trial.
With that angle in mind, an apology that reeks of professional distance comes off as disingenuous, if not borderline insulting. The tone of the Internet at large is incredibly casual, especially in
spaces centered around late Millennial, Gen Z, and early Gen Alpha audiences. Fads and trends rise and fall at a mile a minute. Relevancy is only maintained if a company has a brand reputation that
holds an unshakable honesty under its aesthetic and strategy. When everyone online has the ability and opportunity to become a viral influencer in their own right, they will be choosy regarding who they
publicly endorse, and ruthless with who they condemn. This combination can be seen as a minefield, or as a chance to put one’s most authentic foot forward.
The Bottom Line
A solid brand reputation feeds off of certainty: knowing your values, work ethic, and vision, and adhering to all of them faithfully. At the end of the day, the easiest way to avoid cancel culture in
all of its barbed glory? Stay real, and bring receipts. Evidence of the work you put into your brand and your humanity will, truly, go for miles.
Need help protecting your brand? Contact us to talk strategy.


